Bank sends wrong person $ and it immediately has to be returned or charged will be filed. If I Zelle the wrong person, I am straight SOL. Why the difference?

2.25K views

Exactly what title says, why is there no way to recoup zelle definitely or wire transfer(maybe?) but if banks send money to wrong person there are severe penalties for not returning.

In: 650

84 Answers

1 2 7 8 9
Anonymous 0 Comments

This is an important system that prevents scams. You can’t just say “i sent money by mistake”. For all they know you could be trying to scam the recipient of the money.

Anonymous 0 Comments

> A. Bank sends wrong person $

> B. I Zelle the wrong person

This is a false equivalence. The right way to state it is:

> C. I tell bank to send to wrong person

> D. I tell Zelle to send to wrong person

What happens in case C ? Bank may say tough, you told us to send to X, we sent to X. Same as Zelle.

Then consider:

> E. I tell bank to send to Y, but they send to X

> F. I tell Zelle to send to Y, but they send to X

No difference, I think, both bank and Zelle are on the hook to fix their error.

Anonymous 0 Comments

> A. Bank sends wrong person $

> B. I Zelle the wrong person

This is a false equivalence. The right way to state it is:

> C. I tell bank to send to wrong person

> D. I tell Zelle to send to wrong person

What happens in case C ? Bank may say tough, you told us to send to X, we sent to X. Same as Zelle.

Then consider:

> E. I tell bank to send to Y, but they send to X

> F. I tell Zelle to send to Y, but they send to X

No difference, I think, both bank and Zelle are on the hook to fix their error.

Anonymous 0 Comments

> A. Bank sends wrong person $

> B. I Zelle the wrong person

This is a false equivalence. The right way to state it is:

> C. I tell bank to send to wrong person

> D. I tell Zelle to send to wrong person

What happens in case C ? Bank may say tough, you told us to send to X, we sent to X. Same as Zelle.

Then consider:

> E. I tell bank to send to Y, but they send to X

> F. I tell Zelle to send to Y, but they send to X

No difference, I think, both bank and Zelle are on the hook to fix their error.

1 2 7 8 9