Can light really be poured into a container near absolute zero?

463 views

I thought I had a pretty solid understanding of 0 Kelvin—it’s the temperature at which molecules stop vibrating. What broke my brain was [this](https://www.livescience.com/coldest-temperature-ever) Live Science article says that “light becomes a liquid that can literally be poured into a container” near absolute zero. Is that true? I am skeptical, given that light isn’t a gas or something that can take on another state of matter. The article links a [study](https://www.nature.com/articles/nphys4147.epdf?utm_medium=affiliate&utm_source=commission_junction&utm_campaign=CONR_PF018_ECOM_GL_PHSS_ALWYS_PRODUCT&utm_content=textlink&utm_term=PID100052172&CJEVENT=38280146bcaf11ec839f005a0a82b821) that I can’t possibly decipher, so I was hoping someone smarter than me could help me understand this…

In: 2

5 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

They are discussing entangled bosons in semiconductors, a exciton-photon pairing, in a special material that can form electron holes. The science behind it is called cavity quantum electrodynamics, one application being quantum computers that operate with a single photon. Not light as you know it.

Anonymous 0 Comments

No, it cannot. Like most pop-sci articles, that is extremely misleading to the point of just being totally incorrect. I tried to think of a way to eli5 this but I genuinely don’t think it’s possible because this is somewhat advanced quantum physics. The best I can do is say that they’re interacting light with a special kind of matter with weird properties that you make at extremely close to absolute zero, but that’s the best I can do. Suffice it to say that that article is wrong and light does not become a liquid nor can it be poured into anything.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Since light is massless and do only follow the gravitational lines in spacetime, will you never be able to pure light into anything, not even a black hole. All you do is to release photons in a direction, and all you are doing is bending gravity in an infinitesimal small amount with the container.

Anonymous 0 Comments

It can’t. Absolute zero refers to the thermal energy of a substance being 0, meaning that all the random vibrations we perceive as temperature aren’t happening. Light isn’t a function of those vibrations (and doesn’t act like normal matter anyway) so it doesn’t have a temperature. Absorbed light can heat things up and emitted light can cool things down, but you can’t hear or cool light on its own.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Light can be poured into any container. Light does not become a liquid.

Light obeys gravity. If you have enough gravity at the bottom of a container, light will be poured into the container. That would mean having a black hole at the bottom of the container.

But liquid is a state of matter. Light is not matter and is not in any state of matter.