Do all copper crystals (gems) react to HCl?

189 views

I know native copper does not react to HCI but does react to nitric acid. I’m writing science fiction and I’m trying to create a metallic (non-magnetic) crystal that behaves like calcium but does not react like calcium.
The only solution is to write about something that is copper based. If all copper crystals do react to HCI then it would make this writing process easier so I can make stuff up beyond this point.

I got a C- in high school chemistry. I’m very out of my comfort zone

In: 2

4 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

So when I hear “copper crystal” I think of a metal crystal, like [this](https://hackaday.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/cu.png) (which you can grow at home by the way, really fun).

Since you say gems, there’s malachite and azurite, which are both copper carbonates, malachite being green and azurite a nice blue. But then neither of these are really metallic.

If you want a metal crystal that behaves similarly to calcium, you won’t want copper, but instead beryllium, magnesium, strontium or barium – the group 2 metals. Strontium and barium are generally more reactive than calcium, while magnesium and especially beryllium are less reactive.

So is the premise in your writing that you need to differentiate a calcium crystal from something else?

You are viewing 1 out of 4 answers, click here to view all answers.