Eli5 – how can water be made of hydrogen and oxygen?

466 views

Liquid water – made from two types of gas. Makes no sense to me, whatsoever. Water seems to be one of the strangest substances and we completely take it for granted that, apparently, it’s made of gas!

In: 0

39 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Part of the confusion is the fact that the words “hydrogen” and “oxygen” have multiple and distinct meanings which are often used interchangeably.

Water (a water molecule) is composed of the elements hydrogen and oxygen, specifically an oxygen atom connected to two separate and distinct hydrogen atoms, with the oxygen atom sharing electrons with each hydrogen atom.

“Hydrogen gas” and “oxygen gas” are both ***diatomic molecules***, each composed of two atoms of their respective elements.

Put another way:
The element hydrogen is defined as one proton plus one electron. This is one atom of hydrogen.
The gas known as hydrogen is two hydrogen atoms bound together — that is, two individual protons, sharing two electrons between them, forming a diatomic molecule of hydrogen.

The element oxygen is six protons in a mass with six (sometimes more) neutrons, surrounded by six electrons. This is one atom of oxygen.
Oxygen gas is two atoms of oxygen sharing electrons with one another, forming one diatomic molecule of oxygen.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Gas is just a phase of matter. Hydrogen and oxygen are both solid at certain temperatures and pressures, then liquid, then gas. It’s just that the liquid and solid phases aren’t something you normally come in contact with. But if you’ve ever seen an orbital rocket launch, you’ve seen a tank full of liquid oxygen, and possibly liquid hydrogen (Shuttle and SLS for example).

Then when they join to create H2O, the resulting molecule has completely different chemical properties than either, so its temperatures for the three phases change.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Part of the confusion is the fact that the words “hydrogen” and “oxygen” have multiple and distinct meanings which are often used interchangeably.

Water (a water molecule) is composed of the elements hydrogen and oxygen, specifically an oxygen atom connected to two separate and distinct hydrogen atoms, with the oxygen atom sharing electrons with each hydrogen atom.

“Hydrogen gas” and “oxygen gas” are both ***diatomic molecules***, each composed of two atoms of their respective elements.

Put another way:
The element hydrogen is defined as one proton plus one electron. This is one atom of hydrogen.
The gas known as hydrogen is two hydrogen atoms bound together — that is, two individual protons, sharing two electrons between them, forming a diatomic molecule of hydrogen.

The element oxygen is six protons in a mass with six (sometimes more) neutrons, surrounded by six electrons. This is one atom of oxygen.
Oxygen gas is two atoms of oxygen sharing electrons with one another, forming one diatomic molecule of oxygen.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Part of the confusion is the fact that the words “hydrogen” and “oxygen” have multiple and distinct meanings which are often used interchangeably.

Water (a water molecule) is composed of the elements hydrogen and oxygen, specifically an oxygen atom connected to two separate and distinct hydrogen atoms, with the oxygen atom sharing electrons with each hydrogen atom.

“Hydrogen gas” and “oxygen gas” are both ***diatomic molecules***, each composed of two atoms of their respective elements.

Put another way:
The element hydrogen is defined as one proton plus one electron. This is one atom of hydrogen.
The gas known as hydrogen is two hydrogen atoms bound together — that is, two individual protons, sharing two electrons between them, forming a diatomic molecule of hydrogen.

The element oxygen is six protons in a mass with six (sometimes more) neutrons, surrounded by six electrons. This is one atom of oxygen.
Oxygen gas is two atoms of oxygen sharing electrons with one another, forming one diatomic molecule of oxygen.

Anonymous 0 Comments

It’s not really made of gas. It’s made of atoms. Heck, you’re 9.5% hydrogen by weight. 65% oxygen and 18.5% carbon and a bunch of other stuff.

Note that water is only liquid between 0 and 100 degrees C, or 32 and 212 F. Below that it’s solid, above that is gas. Hydrogen becomes liquid at -253 C, Oxygen is liquid at -183C. That’s because Hydrogen and Oxygen molecules (which are 2 atoms each) don’t tend to stick together unless they get really really cold. Water molecules on the other hand have some local polarity, so they’re more likely to bond at higher temperatures. Pretty much everything has a solid, liquid, and gas temperature.

Anonymous 0 Comments

It’s not really made of gas. It’s made of atoms. Heck, you’re 9.5% hydrogen by weight. 65% oxygen and 18.5% carbon and a bunch of other stuff.

Note that water is only liquid between 0 and 100 degrees C, or 32 and 212 F. Below that it’s solid, above that is gas. Hydrogen becomes liquid at -253 C, Oxygen is liquid at -183C. That’s because Hydrogen and Oxygen molecules (which are 2 atoms each) don’t tend to stick together unless they get really really cold. Water molecules on the other hand have some local polarity, so they’re more likely to bond at higher temperatures. Pretty much everything has a solid, liquid, and gas temperature.

Anonymous 0 Comments

It’s not really made of gas. It’s made of atoms. Heck, you’re 9.5% hydrogen by weight. 65% oxygen and 18.5% carbon and a bunch of other stuff.

Note that water is only liquid between 0 and 100 degrees C, or 32 and 212 F. Below that it’s solid, above that is gas. Hydrogen becomes liquid at -253 C, Oxygen is liquid at -183C. That’s because Hydrogen and Oxygen molecules (which are 2 atoms each) don’t tend to stick together unless they get really really cold. Water molecules on the other hand have some local polarity, so they’re more likely to bond at higher temperatures. Pretty much everything has a solid, liquid, and gas temperature.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Hydrogen and oxygen are not gases, they are solid, liquid or gas depending on temperature. Just like a lot of other stuff like water, and even metals like iron. The difference is the temperature needed for a specific state. You need a very low temperature to turn oxygen and hydrogen into a liquid, Iron, on the other hand, needs a high temperature to become a liquid. The temperature depends on how the molecules/atoms interact with each other

Some more complex molecules break apart if you heat them instead of becoming a liquid so liquid wood is not possible

Both hydrogen and Oxygen form a diatomic compound, two atoms, H2 and O2. The structurally us H-H and O=O where a – is a single valence bound and = is a double valence bound, that is shared electrons.

Water is not a mixture of H2 and O2 is the result of a chemical reaction that produces H2O. If you look at the structure of H2O it is not a line but more like a V with an internal angle of 104.5 degrees

H H
/
O

The result of that geometrical configuration and atoms’ attraction to share electrons is that they end up a bit more of the time at the O and a bit less of the time at the H. The result is that O gets a slightly negative charge and the H is slightly positive. It is called a polar molecule.

Both H2 and O2 are two identical atoms in a line so you do not get sides with different charges.

+ +
H H
/
O

The result is when water is solid or liquid it lines out so the O from one molecule is close to a H of another molecule. That forms a strong intermolecular bond because of the change difference, it requires lots of energy to break. There is two H in a molecule that can bind to O from two different molecules can be bound to the H of a single molecule, you can form large structures like that. A strong bound and molecules that all get bound together result in a high melting and vaporization temperature compared to H2 and O2

The melting point of O2 is −259.16 °C, ​−434.49 °F and the boiling point is −252.879 °C, ​−423.182 °F

The melting point of H2 is (−259.16 °C, ​−434.49 °F and the boiling point i −252.879 °C, ​−423.182 °F

That is a lot lower the water because of weaker bounds between molecules

If you combine hydrogen and carbon you can the Methane CH4. The geometry is

H
|
H-C-H
|
H

Because of the symmetry, there is no part with a negative and positive change and the bounds between atoms are weaker. The melting point is −182.456 °C −296.421 °F and the boiling point is 161.5 °C −258.7 °F That is closer to H2 and O2 than water because it is not polar and binding energies the lower. It is still higher the H2 and O2 because you have 4H on the side that all other elements.

I you have a change of 7 carbon atoms with hydrogen attached you have heptane, C7H16, with a melting temperature of −90.549 °C −130.988 °F; and a boiling temperature of 98.38 °C 209.08 °F. That is liquid at room temperature. Heptane is one of the multiple carbohydrates in gasoline.

If you get to 8 carbon atoms with Octane the boiling temperature is 125C, which is higher than water. If you go to 14 carbon in the chain the melting point is 4C and boiling 254C, so both are higher than water

So the more bounds you have between molecules with just C and H the higher melting and boiling temperature

So melting and boiling temperatures depend both on strength of the bounds between molecules and the number of bounds. Water has stronger bounds the hydrocarbons so they need more bounds to get as high or higher melting and building temperature.

Carbon by itself can bind to 4 other atoms and the result is you can get in theory unlimited molecule size. Graphite and diamonds are just lost carbon atoms in a large molecule. Graphite will break apart if heated to 3630 °C; 6560 °F, it can’t be a liquid at normal atmospheric pressure. The higher temperature is because all of it can be a single molecule and bounds in molecules are stronger between molecules. If you heat water to around 3000C the majority of it will be broken apart too, so a lot more energy is need then to separate water molecules from each other.

This is the explanation for the high melting temperature of some metals too, they can form large crystals with all atoms bound together like carbon but in a slightly different what which results in weaker bonds. The higher melting point of a metals is Tungsten at 3422 °C so slightly lower than when graphite breaks apart

So water is not made of two gases but is a compound of two elements. The melting temperature is a lot higher than just a molecule of the individual element because it gets a positive and negative changed part that results in stronger bounds between molecules so high melting and boiling temperature.

Anonymous 0 Comments

In a gas, molecules fly around freely, with very little interactions between them. In a liquid, molecules are bound together. These bonds break very easily and are in fact broken and reformed all the time. If the bonds were stronger, it would be a solid.

Molecules will tend to stick together for various reasons. For example, hydrogen atoms easily form weak bonds with atoms on the right of the periodic table, like oxygen, fluor… These bonds are called “hydrogen bonds”. (Note that these are bonds between atoms of different molecules. They’re different from the bonds between atoms that form molecules, which are a lot stronger and are called “covalent bonds)

If you have water, hydrogen atoms and oxygen atoms in the water molecules will be attracted to each other. The molecules will stick together and form a liquid. If you have only hydrogen (or only oxygen), they won’t form such bonds and so they will wander freely, forming a gas.

You can give water molecules some energy, by heating them, so that they break these bonds and wander freely too (at 100°C). You can also remove energy from dioxygen molecules, by cooling them, so that they don’t have enough speed, settle down and form a liquid (at around -183°C). But it takes much more energy to break the bonds between water molecules than to break the bonds between dioxygen molecules, so that’s why you have to heat water a lot more to obtain a gas.

Side note : it’s not only water. The boiling point of a molecule doesn’t depend on the boiling point of its atoms. For example, alcohol (named “ethanol” by chemists) is liquid at ambient temperature, but is composed of carbon, hydrogen and oxygen. Carbon is a solid at ambient temperature (it can be the graphite of your pencils, or diamonds), and hydrogen and oxygen are gases.

Anonymous 0 Comments

In a gas, molecules fly around freely, with very little interactions between them. In a liquid, molecules are bound together. These bonds break very easily and are in fact broken and reformed all the time. If the bonds were stronger, it would be a solid.

Molecules will tend to stick together for various reasons. For example, hydrogen atoms easily form weak bonds with atoms on the right of the periodic table, like oxygen, fluor… These bonds are called “hydrogen bonds”. (Note that these are bonds between atoms of different molecules. They’re different from the bonds between atoms that form molecules, which are a lot stronger and are called “covalent bonds)

If you have water, hydrogen atoms and oxygen atoms in the water molecules will be attracted to each other. The molecules will stick together and form a liquid. If you have only hydrogen (or only oxygen), they won’t form such bonds and so they will wander freely, forming a gas.

You can give water molecules some energy, by heating them, so that they break these bonds and wander freely too (at 100°C). You can also remove energy from dioxygen molecules, by cooling them, so that they don’t have enough speed, settle down and form a liquid (at around -183°C). But it takes much more energy to break the bonds between water molecules than to break the bonds between dioxygen molecules, so that’s why you have to heat water a lot more to obtain a gas.

Side note : it’s not only water. The boiling point of a molecule doesn’t depend on the boiling point of its atoms. For example, alcohol (named “ethanol” by chemists) is liquid at ambient temperature, but is composed of carbon, hydrogen and oxygen. Carbon is a solid at ambient temperature (it can be the graphite of your pencils, or diamonds), and hydrogen and oxygen are gases.