Eli5: If creatures such as tardigrades can survive in extreme conditions such as the vacuum of space and deep under water, how can astronauts and other space flight companies be confident in their means of decontamination after missions and returning to earth?

1.18K views

My initial post was related to more of bacteria or organisms on space suits or moon walks and then flown back to earth in the comfort of a shuttle.

In: Biology

28 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Space isn’t usually filled with hot acid. Standard autoclaving procedures handle most terrestrial organisms, but you can use other chemicals and conditions to attack organic molecules directly.

Anonymous 0 Comments

With wide enough boundaries, they can’t. If a tardigrade, or mad space bacteria, can survive a ship going from the vacuum of space to re-entering earth’s atmosphere at enormous heat and then being barracked by the thick earth asmosphere ,then there’s nothing that can reasonably be done. It’s considered sufficiently unlikely to not be a realistic concern.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Tardigrades can handle being frozen and in vacuum and some UV, but probably not all of them for extended periods and definitely not reentry procedures.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Living things generally have a hard time dealing with bleach. Life may be hardy, but humans have developed more than enough harsh chemicals to kill anything organic

Anonymous 0 Comments

To add to what others have said, Even if “something” survives the odds of it being able to live and thrive here on Earth are pretty small. Most living creatures we know of require a lot of additional amino acids, proteins and other various biological compounds to be available to them, and tolerate many others that they don’t need.

An organism from another planet would likely require different ones that don’t exist here, and possibly be poisoned by much of what IS here.

Anonymous 0 Comments

I’m thinking most things that can survive all that already live here or don’t need us to bring them here.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Spacecraft reentry is significantly harder to survive than just “living in space.”

Organisms are usually good at surviving one type of environment very well. Going from the “very cold vacuum of space” to the “very hot and very high pressure entry” is extremely difficult for any organism. Impossible for most.

For things that aren’t exposed to reentry conditions, they are autoclaved (high pressure, high temperature, for lots of time.) Nothing we know can survive that.

In case you haven’t noticed, we ONLY know of life that exists on earth, and if we can kill everything we KNOW of, then that’s generally considered “good enough.”

Furthermore, the organisms that we do know of that can survive conditions like that (for shorter periods of time) aren’t dangerous to humans so we don’t care.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Simply put? There is a measure of “good enough”

100% certainty of decontamination is just not possible without complete annihilation of the object that is being decontaminated, and that would take throwing it into the sun.

Anonymous 0 Comments

ELI5: what the hell are tardigrades and why does OP seem worried about them?

Anonymous 0 Comments

A lot of people are mentioning reentry. What about EVA’s and these organisms attaching themselves to the EVA suits? Once inside, assuming they can survive that atmosphere, they could surely move from the suit to another object.