eli5 If Protein powder is bad for teens how is it worse than natural (non whey/powdered) Protein sources

998 viewsOther

Like if I (a teen) eat 50 gram of protein in a day but I don’t use protein powder how is that any different than half of the protein I consume being whey protein (25/50 grams is protein powder) why is one ok and one apparently bad for your kidneys?

In: Other

16 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Where exactly did you hear that it’s bad for teens?

Anonymous 0 Comments

Where are you reading protein powder is bad for healthy teens or adults? Sounds like someone mislead you.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Another thing to consider is that eating protein comes with a lot of bulk that food is made up of.

The same amount of protein from whey powder 1. Is a concentrated milk product – 50g powder needs 2 litres of milk to produce, and 2. Isn’t balanced with all the things that your guts expect to work on, regarding water content, fibre, and fats.

Your digestive system hasn’t adapted to work with food isolates – it copes better with the whole food (or at least something nutritionally balanced).

You’re essentially taking the protein equivalent of roughly 200g solid, chewy food (meat/nuts) that digests slowly, consists of a multitude of carbs/fats, and gives your intestines something to push against, and instead having it in an isolated, rapid liquid sludge form.

Who needs teeth?

Anonymous 0 Comments

Protein powder isn’t bad for teenagers, but some people think is the same as steroids. If you have some problem with your kidneys it can worsen it as many other things can but for a healthy person protein powder is a good supplement

Anonymous 0 Comments

Who the hell told you protein powder is bad for your kidneys?

Anonymous 0 Comments

It’s not bad for your kidneys but maybe just eat more chicken?