Eli5: Why aren’t teams from the economic centers of the United States, such as New York, dominant in basketball or American football?

781 viewsOther

In other countries, especially in sports like football (soccer), teams from major urban centers tend to dominate leagues and championships, often because of higher financial resources. However, this doesn’t seem to be the case in the United States, where titles in major sports like basketball and American football are more evenly spread among cities or regions. For example, about football in other countries, it seems almost impossible for a team located in a city similar to where the Green Bay Packers are located to be relevant. Just look at the history of the Premier League, Bundesliga, or La Liga.Perhaps the question is more about why titles are more evenly distributed among regions in these sports in United States, comparing with other countries.

In: Other

14 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

They are. Your premise is incorrect.

The NFL teams with the most championships are:

1. New England Patriots (Boston) – 6
2. Pittsburgh Steelers – 6
3. Dallas Cowboys – 5
4. San Francisco 49ers – 5
5. Green Bay Packers – 4
6. New York Giants – 4

Green Bay is an anomaly rather than the norm. The 5 other teams with 4 or more championships are all from major urban centers.

The MLB teams with the most championships are:

1. New York Yankees – 27
2. St. Louis Cardinals – 11
3. Philadelphia/Kansas City/Oakland Athletics – 9 (5 in Philly between 1910-1930, 4 in Oakland between 1972 and 1989)
4. Boston Red Sox – 9
5. New York/San Francisco Giants – 8 (5 in NY between 1905 and 1954, 3 in SF between 2010 and 2014)
6. Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers – 7 (1 in Brooklyn in 1955, 6 in LA from 1959 to 2020)

All 6 MLB teams with 7 or more World Series are from major urban centers.

You are viewing 1 out of 14 answers, click here to view all answers.