ELi5: Why do people dislike stock buybacks, but not stock dividends?

2.53K views

How are stock buybacks any worse than dividend payouts to investors?

I get how they are logistically different, but to me, whether you give the investors cash that they use to buy more stock, or you internally increase the value of a stock by buying it back with company funds, the result is the same – Investors get richer at the cost of investment.

Not saying buybacks aren’t bad, but I guess I just don’t understand the hate relative to dividend payments.

In: 98

67 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Stock buybacks often deplete cash reserves, and if the stock then goes down the company is in even worse shape than before. And if the stock goes up, there’s a reluctance to sell to generate cash, so again, operating cash is too low. But for a while it was seen as “what all the smart finance people are doing” so a lot of companies that should not have done it, did it.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Because it’s a buzzword. People also don’t understand the step-up method for stocks when people inherit. They just get irrationally mad that rich people exist.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Buyback are investigating in yout self. Dividends are investing in others. I see the difference.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Buyback are investigating in yout self. Dividends are investing in others. I see the difference.

Anonymous 0 Comments

People hate both but baybacka have been in the media recently. It’s hard not to hate it when a company get bailed with public money, then fires a bunch of people or cuts wages due to the economy, then posts record profits and spends it on stock buyback.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Buyback are investigating in yout self. Dividends are investing in others. I see the difference.

Anonymous 0 Comments

People hate both but baybacka have been in the media recently. It’s hard not to hate it when a company get bailed with public money, then fires a bunch of people or cuts wages due to the economy, then posts record profits and spends it on stock buyback.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Dividends are getting rent.

Stock buyback is your neighbor selling their house, and hopefully the value of your house goes up.

Anonymous 0 Comments

People hate both but baybacka have been in the media recently. It’s hard not to hate it when a company get bailed with public money, then fires a bunch of people or cuts wages due to the economy, then posts record profits and spends it on stock buyback.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Dividends are getting rent.

Stock buyback is your neighbor selling their house, and hopefully the value of your house goes up.