Eli5: Why do they say windchill doesn’t affect objects yet fans are used for cooling?

1.17K viewsOtherPhysics

Basically title, you always hear “windchill only affects humans” but we use fans to cool things all the time?

In: Physics

22 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

It ultimately affects objects the same as humans. It just happens that humans are wet, warm objects.

A wet object loses heat by evaporating water to dryer surrounding air. This forms a layer of moist air, that slows down evaporation. The moisture moves away slowly through the air, wind instead just replaces the moist air.

A warm object loses heat to cooler air simply by heat flowing from hot to cold naturally. This forms a layer of somewhat warmer air, slowing the cooling, with the heat moving away to cooler air slowly. Air, that does not move, is particularly slow at this. Wind speeds it up, by replacing the heated air by cooler air. Additionally, hot air is less dense than cold air, so the heat transfer is causing some amount of “wind” by itself. Hence why we insulate buildings and clothing with material, that traps a lot of air, and why even perfectly air-tight windows can cause some “draft” when it is cold outside.

Both effects work also the other way around. Hotter-than-object air heats the object, and if water can condense from wet air to a dry object, the condensation heats the object. Wind helps to replenish heat and humidity in those cases.

So “wind chill” is really just wind speeding up what already happens, if the object happens to be warm and moist and whether the human body counts as warm and moist depends on the weather conditions.

Also, the human body maintains its “wet and warm” state by eating and drinking. Using energy from the food produces waste heat. Humans in particular also sweat as a way of actively making the *surface* wet for the sake of cooling.

By contrast, a typical inert object will over time adjust its wetness and temperature to the air. Then, and only then, wind will not affect it. Temperature and humidity change over the day, but slowly, so the effect will never be *much*.

Unless there is a sudden change, such as taking food out of the pot. Now you have a hot, wet object, that you can cool with wind.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Anything that is hotter than the surrounding air is radiating heat from itself to the air making the air warmer. If the air isn’t moving then the only air moving away from the object is the air escaping upwards due to warm air being less dense than cold air. As a result you lose efficiency because the warmer air has reduced effectiveness in removing heat because it’s closer in temperature to the object. By introducing a current to the air by use of a fan you are ensuring that the heated air is moved away from the object as fast as possible meaning more cooler air can come into contact with it and that cooler air maintains a higher temperature differential between the object and the air which you need to radiate the heat into.