ELI5. Why do you need to use heavy hydrogen to start a fusion reaction?

490 viewsOtherPhysics

I am pretty sure the sun fuses just standard one proton hydrogen. So why do we need to use deuterium and tritium for our bombs?

In: Physics

7 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Technically, you don’t. Practically, however, the required energies are much, much lower if you start at heavy hydrogen than hydrogen-1.

In the Sun, the initial fusion of Hydrogen-1 does not create helium-2 (which is incredibly unstable due to the repelling “electromagnetic force” on protons being able to overcome the attractive “strong force” when no neutron is present). Instead, when 2 Hydrogen-1 fuse they turn into Hydrogen-2, releasing a neutrino and a positron. This requires a lot of input energy and we are not currently capable of doing it on large scales.

The next step is that Hydrogen-2 and Hydrogen-1 fuse into Helium-3, which is stable, and releases gamma radiation as a result. This is where we start for hydrogen bombs, because the input energy required is much lower, and the energy output is quite high. Two Helium-3 then fuse into a Helium-4, releasing 2 Hydrogen-1 in the process, to finish the fusion reaction as completed within the sun. This last step is not done in nuclear bombs at a large scale as the explosion tends to scatter material before it reaches this stage.

You are viewing 1 out of 7 answers, click here to view all answers.