Eli5 why is it hard to tap your head and rub your belly at the same time then switch hands?

99 views

Eli5 why is it hard to tap your head and rub your belly at the same time then switch hands?

In: 2

4 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

I’m not a kinesiologist or anything, but I am a conductor. In our training, we spend some time practicing things like this to gain “hand independence”. People tend to be able to mirror their movements well (symmetry), or alternate their movements (right left right left), but doing two dissimilar things gets more complicated. Tapping and rubbing, in two different dimensional spaces (patting is up and down, rubbing is circular) is just hard enough to not come naturally. After decades of practice I can do things like this without thinking about them, but it took practice.

There are all sorts of fun ways to practice. One of the hardest we had was, stand facing a chalkboard with a piece of chalk in each hand. Draw a square with one hand, and a circle with the other, simultaneously. Another basic one is sitting at a table, draw clockwise circles with your finger. At some point as that’s going on, lift your right foot, and with your toe draw a “6” in the air.

Anonymous 0 Comments

I’m not a kinesiologist or anything, but I am a conductor. In our training, we spend some time practicing things like this to gain “hand independence”. People tend to be able to mirror their movements well (symmetry), or alternate their movements (right left right left), but doing two dissimilar things gets more complicated. Tapping and rubbing, in two different dimensional spaces (patting is up and down, rubbing is circular) is just hard enough to not come naturally. After decades of practice I can do things like this without thinking about them, but it took practice.

There are all sorts of fun ways to practice. One of the hardest we had was, stand facing a chalkboard with a piece of chalk in each hand. Draw a square with one hand, and a circle with the other, simultaneously. Another basic one is sitting at a table, draw clockwise circles with your finger. At some point as that’s going on, lift your right foot, and with your toe draw a “6” in the air.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Basically, moving both arms in the same way is easy because you only have to think of one movement, and just copy it on both sides. To tap your head and rub your belly at the same time, you need to use more brain power to concentrate on your movement(s). That’s why getting into the rhythm of it is hard, but easy once you get used to it and don’t have to focus on it as much. Switching it would disrupt this rhythm, making it more difficult. With practice it would get easier to switch randomly, because of muscle memory. But picking up on new movements would still be more challenging than just moving your arms in unison

So TLDR; similar movements = less brain power, movements that aren’t very similar = more brain power

Anonymous 0 Comments

Basically, moving both arms in the same way is easy because you only have to think of one movement, and just copy it on both sides. To tap your head and rub your belly at the same time, you need to use more brain power to concentrate on your movement(s). That’s why getting into the rhythm of it is hard, but easy once you get used to it and don’t have to focus on it as much. Switching it would disrupt this rhythm, making it more difficult. With practice it would get easier to switch randomly, because of muscle memory. But picking up on new movements would still be more challenging than just moving your arms in unison

So TLDR; similar movements = less brain power, movements that aren’t very similar = more brain power