How are spacecraft parts both extremely fragile and able to stand up to tremendous stress?

1.65K views

The other day I was watching a documentary about Mars rovers, and at one point a story was told about a computer on the rover that almost had to be completely thrown out because someone dropped a tool on a table next to it. Not on it, next to it. This same rover also was planned to land by a literal freefall; crash landing onto airbags. And that’s not even covering vibrations and G-forces experienced during the launch and reaching escape velocity.

I’ve heard similar anecdotes about the fragility of spacecraft. Apollo astronauts being nervous that a stray floating object or foot may unintentionally rip through the thin bulkheads of the lunar lander. The Hubble space telescope returning unclear and almost unusable pictures due to an imperfection in the mirror 1/50th the thickness of a human hair, etc.

How can NASA and other space agencies be confident that these occasionally microscopic imperfections that can result in catastrophic consequences will not happen during what must be extreme stresses experienced during launch, travel, or re-entry/landing?

​

​

EDIT: Thank you for all the responses, but I think that some of you are misunderstanding the question. Im not asking why spacecraft parts are made out of lightweight materials and therefore are naturally more fragile than more durable ones. Im also not asking why they need to be 100% sure that the part remains operational.

I’m asking why they can be confident that parts which have such a low potential threshold for failure can be trusted to remain operational through the stresses of flight.

In: 3487

25 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Keep in mind also that many things are extremely strong *in one specific way.* Bridge cables can hold up hundreds of tons but can be bent with a finger. Foils and plating can withstand thousands of degrees of heat but be soft enough to scrape with a fingernail. The list goes on.

And since spacecraft tend to spend their time… in space… you don’t have to design for generic atmospheric survivability as much.

They survive launch because they’re carefully packed and padded and not allowed to move. Fairings keep the wind and air from hitting them, bracing prevents knocks and shocks and sharp collisions.

You are viewing 1 out of 25 answers, click here to view all answers.