How can screwing a massively heavy object to a wall with four screws (like a water tank) be safe? I feel its always going to fall, taking a piece of the wall with it.

817 viewsOtherPhysics

Or screwing workout equipment which you constantly pull with your own weight.

EDIT: Forgot to add, I’m not in the US, I’m talking about brick or concrete walls, not drywalls. Although probably the basic principle applies when it comes to explaining how force works.

In: Physics

17 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

You dont normally use normal screws for stuff like that either heavy duty screws into something like a stud that can support a lot of weight or something like toggle bolts which are actually pretty clever. They spead out behind the drywall once inserted and spread the force of the weight out along a greater area of wall rather than a single spot. Basically taking advantage of physics. You can drastically increased the amount of weight a wall can support that way as well.

Anonymous 0 Comments

You’re not screwing it to the wall.  You’re screwing it to the wood support beam behind the wall.  So long as the screw is long enough it’s not gonna move

Anonymous 0 Comments

Think of it like a big cup of water. When you try and push the cup over, the water in the bottom doesn’t want to let it fall over, and it’ll just tip back upright. But if you push it JUST far enough, the weight of the water makes it tip all the way and spill all over. Screwing the top of the cup to a wall prevents it from ever getting to that tipping point, even if it doesn’t have any water in it.

Anonymous 0 Comments

If you’re talking about masonry walls, it’s pretty simple. Masonry is really dense and strong. It literally is supporting a building. The 100 or so pounds is negligible as long as the screws can hold the weight. That being said I’ve never seen a fish tank hanging on a wall in a house. They’re generally on a stand because of how heavy they are.

But the basic answer is bricks and concretas are really strong. As long as you drill into them properly, they can hold a ton of weight.

Anonymous 0 Comments

It works by applying force across the screws and the walls. Where the closer you are to the wall, the more the force is distributed across the wall and the screws. And each screw applied distributes that force from the equipment more evenly.

Kind of like a bed of nails. The more nails you have the more the weight is distributed. To the point each nail is taking up just a pound or less.

Anonymous 0 Comments

If in doubt, and if I’m hanging anything – excluding small stuff obviously, I use expanding bolts, so I don’t have to have that niggle in the back of my mind of if/when something gives out. I do a lot of “odd bits” for folk, and find the standard fitting supplied with so many things “ok” but, just that. Big fat expanding bolts are the way forward, they havn’t let me down yet 👌🏾

Anonymous 0 Comments

You’re screwing it into the framing behind it. That framing is either wood that is being compressed as the screws enter, holding a very tight grip on it, or it’s metal framing that has very high strength potential.