How do the economics of valet-only parking garages in NYC work?

Question

I’m fascinated by the modalities of owning a car in NYC. I’ve read that most people don’t have assigned parking spaces and use garages, which often have 24-hr waits for accessing one’s vehicle since a valet needs time to get it out of a tightly packed space. This is backed up by multiple sources \[1\]\[2\].

I’m figuring, a hypothetical garage that let people self-park whenever they want would command a price premium for the convenience, and save on the staffing costs of valets. How is it that such a garage doesn’t come into existence and put the valet-only garages out of business?

\[1\] [https://jalopnik.com/owning-a-car-in-new-york-is-absolutely-worth-it-1782352176](https://jalopnik.com/owning-a-car-in-new-york-is-absolutely-worth-it-1782352176)\[2\] SpotHero’s guide to NYC parking – link omitted since it has a chance of triggering a spam filter

Edit: It looks like the point about taking 24 hrs to retrieve a car is out-of-date – it’s more like 30 mins.

In: Economics

Answer 1

Thanks, all, for your answers, and letting me know that the premise of taking 24 hours to unpark was out-of-date. Your answers explain the situation really well.