how does instinct work? If it’s just “baked” into an animal’s DNA, how does it “activate” and how does it “activate” successfully?

835 views

how does instinct work? If it’s just “baked” into an animal’s DNA, how does it “activate” and how does it “activate” successfully?

In: 513

48 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

A lot of answers here do a decent job of explaining what “instinct” _is_, but not how it “activates” or comes to be.

Beyond just the “pre-programmed circuits” that respond to different inputs (such as increased alertness when hearing certain sounds, or that possum playing dead, even while the coyote peed on it), it’s important to realize that members of a species that _didn’t_ respond that way tended to die. If they died before procreating, their “bad instinct” programming didn’t get passed on.

Consider a bird chick that, hypothetically, never picks up on the instinct to fly: it will probably die young. Same for migratory birds; the ones that _don’t_ have the instinct to head south (assuming northern hemisphere) would likely die in the winter (though nowadays, I’m sure some would find food and shelter with people, possibly perpetuating that lack of instinct).

The really wild “instinct” for me is monarch butterfly migrations. It’s several generations for one migratory cycle, so I’m not really sure how that works; but it must, since it does.

Anonymous 0 Comments

A lot of answers here do a decent job of explaining what “instinct” _is_, but not how it “activates” or comes to be.

Beyond just the “pre-programmed circuits” that respond to different inputs (such as increased alertness when hearing certain sounds, or that possum playing dead, even while the coyote peed on it), it’s important to realize that members of a species that _didn’t_ respond that way tended to die. If they died before procreating, their “bad instinct” programming didn’t get passed on.

Consider a bird chick that, hypothetically, never picks up on the instinct to fly: it will probably die young. Same for migratory birds; the ones that _don’t_ have the instinct to head south (assuming northern hemisphere) would likely die in the winter (though nowadays, I’m sure some would find food and shelter with people, possibly perpetuating that lack of instinct).

The really wild “instinct” for me is monarch butterfly migrations. It’s several generations for one migratory cycle, so I’m not really sure how that works; but it must, since it does.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Interesting question. I think of it like this and let’s use eating as the activity. Our body and mind develop the parts needed mouth, digestive system and the neural connections to control and receive information. So a baby is born and knows how to suckle right off the start. The babies lips touch and they start to suckle. Instincts seem to be more to biological survival activities of the individual or the species.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Interesting question. I think of it like this and let’s use eating as the activity. Our body and mind develop the parts needed mouth, digestive system and the neural connections to control and receive information. So a baby is born and knows how to suckle right off the start. The babies lips touch and they start to suckle. Instincts seem to be more to biological survival activities of the individual or the species.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Interesting question. I think of it like this and let’s use eating as the activity. Our body and mind develop the parts needed mouth, digestive system and the neural connections to control and receive information. So a baby is born and knows how to suckle right off the start. The babies lips touch and they start to suckle. Instincts seem to be more to biological survival activities of the individual or the species.

Anonymous 0 Comments

There’s research that has shown that memories can be passed down through DNA.

I’ve seen it theorized that that is why we have nightmares about wolves and such when we are children even if we’ve never seen or heard of what a wolf is, it might be that our ancestors passed down that instinctual fear of wolves through our DNA.

Anonymous 0 Comments

There’s research that has shown that memories can be passed down through DNA.

I’ve seen it theorized that that is why we have nightmares about wolves and such when we are children even if we’ve never seen or heard of what a wolf is, it might be that our ancestors passed down that instinctual fear of wolves through our DNA.

Anonymous 0 Comments

There’s research that has shown that memories can be passed down through DNA.

I’ve seen it theorized that that is why we have nightmares about wolves and such when we are children even if we’ve never seen or heard of what a wolf is, it might be that our ancestors passed down that instinctual fear of wolves through our DNA.