Japan has been given the okay by UN to dump radioactive waste water into the ocean, but nearby countries are protesting that its unsafe. Is it unsafe? Is it safe?

809 views

Japan has been given the okay by UN to dump radioactive waste water into the ocean, but nearby countries are protesting that its unsafe. Is it unsafe? Is it safe?

In: 4128

33 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

It’s as safe as anything in life, for a couple of key reasons:

* Compared to the volume of water they’ll be discharging, the ocean is *absolutely freaking massive*. Like, the difference in scale is utterly absurd. It’s like putting a drop of food dye into the volume of several olympic swimming pools.
* The water has been heavily processed to remove almost all of the radioactive isotopes from it. About the only thing they can’t readily remove is tritium – basically hydrogen atoms with a couple extra neutrons.
* Because extra neutrons don’t change the charge of an atom, they’ don’t really affect its *chemical* properties, so those ^(3)H atoms have bonded with oxygen to become part of water molecules – can’t *really* separate them without, idk, electrolysis and a bunch of gas centrifuging or something.
* Tritium does eventually release its extra neutrons, and those free neutrons bouncing around *are* ionizing radiation. But the amount and energy of the radiation is pretty low. It’s *beta* radiation –
* outside you, it can’t even penetrate your skin (although large amounts of exposure in a short time could give you the equivalent of a sunburn).
* if it gets inside you *in large amounts* it can increase your overall cancer risk, but it would take quite a lot of concentrated tritiated water to actually cause harm.

You are viewing 1 out of 33 answers, click here to view all answers.