I intuitively know this, kind of like I intuitively know what a species is. I also accept that language is imperfect and there’s gonna be messy bits where things don’t fit right (again, like a definition of a biological species).
But if linguists and other languagey folks were to put a group of English speakers on another planet and let them live there for x amount of time, going back to study their language from time to time, what markers would they look for to say “this is now not a group with new slang, this is a group with a new dialect”? And “this is not the same language as the English spoken on Earth”?
In: 41
The essential distinction between a language and a dialect is not just a messy gray area; it literally doesn’t exist, in that linguists have taken no real interest in the question. The issue is entirely political. This distinction is not academic in nature.
Latest Answers