The logic behind the probability of two people sharing a birthday being 1/365 is thus:
Pick a date at random(say March 1). What are the odds that person A birthday is March 1? 1/365. What are the odds of person B having a birthdate of March 1? 1/365. Odds of A and B having birthdate March 1?
P(A and B) = (1/365)* (1/365)
Now the question isnt about a particular date, but rather if they share a birthday regardless of the date. So we need to calculate the probability of not just March 1 but every possible date in the calendar(not assuming leap year), which is 365. So the probability becomes 365 times P(A and B) which is:
= 365* (1/365)* (1/365)
= 1/365.
There you go
It’s only a *veridical* paradox, which just means that it defies the natural assumptions our brains make.
Briefly, lets look at a coin flip. What are the odds we *don’t* get heads? There is:
0.5 chance to not get heads once.
0.5*0.5=0.25 chance to not get heads twice.
0.5^n to not get heads n times.
We get a basic formula from this for how probability changes for the number of samples. If p is the probability and n is the number, then the formula is p^n
For the birthday paradox, we use the same tactic, but instead ask the odds of two people *not* sharing a birthday.
Because the people are random, each pair has the exact same chance to *not* share a birthday, 364/365.
We can form 253 *unique* pairs of people from a group of 23. If we name them A-W, A has 22 possible pairs, B has 21 since we don’t want to count A again, and this goes on for each person.
So our formula is:
(364/365)^253 = 0.4995 chance they *don’t* share a birthday. This means:
0.5005 chance they *do* share a birthday.
**The Math:**
(364/365)^253 = 0.4995
**The Explanation:**
253 unique pairs come from 23 people.
364/365 chance they *dont* share a birthday.
Like a coin flip, each time we check we are actually multiplying the odds exponentially. With a coin flip the probability is 0.5, but here it is 364/365.
So the result, 0.4995, is the odds they don’t share a birthday. That means the odds they *do* share a birthday is 0.5005, or 50.05%
It is a veridical paradox, which just means it defies our brains’ natural assumptions. It isn’t a paradox in the traditional sense.
Latest Answers