Why are Hindi and Urdu are considered separate languages but Moroccan Arabic and Iraqi Arabic are considered the same language?

303 views

My understanding is the main difference between Hindi and Urdu is that Hindi is in Devanagari script and Urdu is in a modified form of Arabic Script, and they can understand each others spoken language with ease, whereas Moroccans and Iraqis cannot understand each other at all. Why is this?

In: 112

9 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Hindi and Urdu are not in fact separate languages, but two prestige dialects of one language. The distinction developed in the late nineteenth century as a result of colonial religious politics. More specifically, they are two registers of a single dialect, Khari Boli, which is historically spoken in the Delhi region. There are other dialects, including ones with rich literary traditions, notably Dakhni and Braj, but for a variety of reasons rather than developing out of any of these, modern standard Hindi was deliberately crafted from Khari Boli by abandoning the Nastaliq script, Perso-Arabic vocabulary, and also suppressing Indic/tadbhava vocabulary in favor of neologisms derived from Sanskrit. Despite all this, more than a century later speakers of standard Hindi and standard Urdu can easily understand each other until they begin using formal/literary/technical vocabulary.

You are viewing 1 out of 9 answers, click here to view all answers.