The musical scales are A B C D E F G A, or Do Re Mi Fa So La Ti Do. If you do it that way, yes, there are eight. But the last note is the same as the first but at a higher pitch. If this were math, we’d basically be dealing with a base-7 system, with A or Do playing the part of zero.
So why is the set of scales called an octave if it’s all based on a base-7 system?
EDIT: Many of the first answers from when I originally asked were helpful but now I’m getting a lot of wrong answers from people who don’t seem to understand how numbers work. In a base-8 system, there are eight unique numbers, 0 through 7, after which it goes to 10. If you translate the notes into numbers, you don’t get 0 through 7, though. You get 0 through 6, after which it goes to 10 at the second Do. That’s why I was trying to reconcile that with the term “octave.”
In: 233
For the same reason that Jesus rose on “the third day”: the starting point is counted as one. The octave – note VIII – was so named by a culture that had not yet absorbed the concept of zero. (Arguably it still has not; *The Art of Computer Programming*, of all things, almost always counts from one even when counting from zero would make its algorithms much more transparent.)
Latest Answers