why are we so certain that water and oxygen are required for alien life?

1.38K views

We’re assuming that alien life requires the same things we do, why?

In: Biology

20 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

So, ask a group of microbiologists sometime “what makes a microorganism alive or not” and grab popcorn. I actually did this (me, non-scientist working w scientists). The debate got heated.

I mention this because I think the question you ask is great, but it also uncovers a more fundamental question. If we don’t agree, scientifically, about what is alive and what isn’t—or even the criteria for deciding—then are we on a wild goose chase anyway? Do we need to return to first principles? I e wondered this for years.

You are viewing 1 out of 20 answers, click here to view all answers.