100% culture.
A wonderfully good example is the Indonesian gamelan, which to our Western ears sounds completely discordant, while to them culturally it represents something more harmonious.
[https://youtu.be/UEWCCSuHsuQ?si=bd7ADBLWh-vTRAS1](https://youtu.be/UEWCCSuHsuQ?si=bd7ADBLWh-vTRAS1)
It even sounds ominous at times I guess to some listeners from the West, even though to Indonesians these are associated with either some kind of joyous and busy tone or more formal/ceremonial/sacred tone (depending on the exact tuning/notation). It’s very much culture and it seems sounds themselves are just… sounds and don’t have innate meanings.
Latest Answers