Why does mayonnaise act and taste the same as butter if you fry it on a grilled cheese sandwhich?

1.68K views

My grandad taught me this trick when I was like 7 and old enough to make a grilled cheese, and it was like magic to me, and is still really, I just thought about it and I really don’t know any food chemistry so naturally brought me to reddit to seek out my tasty answer.

In: Chemistry

19 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

[removed]

Anonymous 0 Comments

[removed]

Anonymous 0 Comments

Mayo has two primary ingredients; fat (oil)and protein (egg). The fat transfers heat to the bread, while the protein browns up nicely.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Mayonnaise is primarily made from oil. It is perfectly usable as a substitute for frying if the egg protein and spices won’t throw off the taste of whatever you’re doing too much. I’ve used it for grilled cheese and bologna sandwiches. You could fry taters in it etc.. It will just break down into oil when you heat it.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Mayo is fat + egg.

Butter is fat + water.

The fat does all the work, so you should have a somewhat similar thing here, you’re just cooking mostly fat onto bread.

And yes, if you’re wondering, you can make homemade mayo, and yes its just oil and egg (although you’re welcome to throw some extra stuff in for flavor)

Anonymous 0 Comments

Not a good chemist either but mayonnaise has a ton of fat in it so that should be what is browning the bread and making it crunchy. Personally having tried both I’m still a butter person myself but to each their own.

Anonymous 0 Comments

[removed]

Anonymous 0 Comments

Because it isn’t the dominant flavour of the sandwich.

You’re mostly tasting the cheese and bread, so mayo or butter will only slightly change the overall flavour.

Anonymous 0 Comments

[removed]

Anonymous 0 Comments

[removed]