Why does moving towards, say, a punch while blocking make it hurt less?

257 viewsOtherPhysics

Why does moving towards, say, a punch while blocking make it hurt less?

In: Physics

3 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

It’s a bit like a collision with any accelerating object. Imagine you were going to get hit by a car, and the car starts fully parked. 

Would you rather make contact one foot away from where it was parked, or 20 feet away, assuming the pedal stayed the same depth the whole time? The car will be going much faster and therefore be more damaging once it’s 20 feet away than when it’s 1 foot away, so if you must take the hit, closer is safer. 

With a punch, there’s also the issue of not only acceleration but also recruiting power from more muscles (getting more “weight”) into it as it nears its optimal range, but the basic principle is the same.  

Incidentally, that’s why Bruce Lee’s “one inch punch” is such an impressive trick. It’s very hard to deliver an effective punch if the target is only one inch from your fist because there’s no room to accelerate and recruit more mass.

EDIT; also, one important detail that is specific to punches. Usually when you move into a straight punch, you also tilt down your head so that the fist connects with your forehead instead of your chin. This shrinks the distance but also greatly increases the chance that their hand will be injured since your skull is more solid than your jaw.

Anonymous 0 Comments

because you’re basically giving the other person less time to put their whole strength into it.

think about throwing something like a ball or a rock and if you release it too early, it doesn’t go as far

Anonymous 0 Comments

In general, the closer you are when the person throws a punch, your block will prevent their arm from being fully extended. And the closer the distance you are to the puncher, the less torque and weight is generated. So, it reduces the strength of the punch.

However, It can also have the opposite effect. If you are going towards a punch, and your timing is off, you can get hit with a counter punch. Your weight going into the punch plus their fist with their weight hitting your face can hurt you a lot.

Something like that. There is more to it than my explanation, but that is the jist of it.

Someone will explain it better than I. Lol