Why does the USA do ‘sobriety field tests’ for suspected DUIs?

1.36K viewsOther

When other countries (notably Europe) use roadside ‘Breathalyzer’ test machines? It seems a high-functioning drunk could get away with DUI in the US, when they wouldn’t in France or the UK?

In: Other

27 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

There are two main reasons. The first is that a roadside breath test only detects alcohol but a driver can be impaired by other substances.

The second is that the actual results of a roadside breathalyzer are generally inadmissible in a criminal trial outside of specific circumstances. Normally an officer can only testify that the PBT detected the presence of alcoholic beverage, not the actual number. I was a local cop at two different agencies, neither issued PBTs for this reason.

Case law in the US considers the roadside olympics to be more accurate than the roadside breath test.

You are viewing 1 out of 27 answers, click here to view all answers.