Why is it illegal to share your screen via Discord, etc. when watching Netflix – and how is it differentiated from people sitting on your couch next to you to watch alongside you?

Question

To further explain, the concept is the same, isn’t it? Watching IRL you can have 2, 3, 10 people around one screen. Online, you can do the same thing by sharing your screen through Discord and similar apps, but in that case it is illegal, you can get accounts banned, warned, etc. and is seemingly considered to be piracy. What is the actual difference between the two?

In: Other

Answer 1

physicality and expected privacy

your home is a private place; discord/twitch are not

sharing a movie/cd/other media with people person to person is different from putting 1 cd on a table and then 600 strangers all take that one CD

legally there are some grey areas; so im sure some companies just ban it to avoid potential legal trouble