It supposedly helps with fair price discovery, and hinders that when not allowed.
You see anyone who thinks a share is undervalued can expressly state so by buying it.
However if you think a share is overvalued what you would do to express this sentiment is sell it, which you couldn’t do otherwise if you don’t actually have shares. That would be an inherent unbalance.
Otherwise? Because it’s never been forbidden and that is because it never caused trouble before. It used to even be allowed to short shares that you didn’t have at all, without borrowing them. Granted only intra-day since you can’t have a negative amount of shares once you get to clearing, but still that existed.
And even if short selling were disallowed, what would that accomplish really? The short answer is practically nothing. The effect of short selling a share? You can always do pretty much the same through the options market by selling calls or buying puts.
Latest Answers