Can one freeze water instead of boiling to make it safe to drink? Why or why not?

3.42K views
0

This is in the context of well/tap water that doesn’t meet “potable water” requirements due to lack of inspection thoroughness/frequency

In: Chemistry

Freezing does not kill microorganisms (unless we’re talking very, *very* low temperatures, much lower than the freezing point of water), so freezing water would not make it safe to drink in most cases.

While boiling usually is hot enough to kill, on the hot end of the spectrum. (Although, in canning low acid foods, it requires pressure and extend time to make things completely sterile and shelf stable.)

Not really. All it does is make them inactive until you thaw them. Sure, you may kill some of them when ice crystals form inside the bacterial walls, but it won’t be enough to make the water safe to drink.

Heat kills things because high temperatures triggers chemical reactions which irreversibly destroy some important things. For us humans, this starts happening when our skin reaches around ~60°C. Some microorganisms have found ways to survive even higher temperatures, but ultimately a temperature above 120°C will kill (nearly) all living things, with the exception of some very rare extremophile “archaea” found in thermal springs.

Cold does the opposite. It stops chemical reactions. The way that cold can kill is that ice crystals can grow and expand in ways that pierces cell membrane. That’s why most vegetables will turn to mush if frozen in a household freezer. But bacteria have found a way to survive this: They can turn themselves into a dormant form, where they are almost completely dried out. In this form, these so called spores are not vulnerable to ice formation, so they can survive even extremely low temperatures.

There are common super tiny living things called Giardia that are kind of like turtles. When they see a dangerous environment they hide away in their shell that they call a cyst. When you freeze the water the little Giardia just hang out in their shell which is insulated like a cozy cabin. But when you boil water it gets too hot in the shell so the Giardia have to leave their cyst/ Shell where they are exposed and then killed.