are carbs or sugars in foods like bread or crackers “equal” to those in fruits?

2.71K views

I saw my friend eating a banana, and he said “I’m trying to eat more fruits instead of junk like bread and crackers”, and my other friend said “that doesn’t matter. Carbs are carbs.”

Now at face value, it seems a bit silly: we are all brought up to believe that fruits have other nutrients that are beneficial to us. But in the end, are the carbs in both sources the same? Similarly, can one say that the sugars one obtains in a fruit are the same as those obtained in a candy bar?

My intuitive understanding is, while “sugar” is in fact just sugar (irrespective of the source), the reason we consider fruits or vegetables important is because of the other nutrients and vitamins they contain, giving them an overall better nutritional profile than their processed counterparts. In addition, I think that the chemical modifications that manufacturers make to their goods are considered unhealthy. But In the end, is it fair to say that a “carb is just a carb”? Or sugar a sugar?

In: Biology

7 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

1. carbs are not carbs are not carbs.
2. to your liver, sugar is sugar. Be it from fruits or honey or Nutella, sugar is processed as sugar. The only difference between white sugar and the sugar you get from a fruit is that in white sugar you get nothing else, whereas from a fruit you get nutrients. But the sugar is processed the same by your body.

You are viewing 1 out of 7 answers, click here to view all answers.