Eli5: Do manual fans ever work?

565 views

I’ve heard my whole life that “you burn more energy waving a fan than by just not moving” and I was wondering if there was any truth to this. I’m currently using a foldable paper fan and it seems to be pretty effective. I don’t have an air conditioner so this is a dire situation

In: Biology

4 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

You burn more energy doing something compared to not doing it, sure, but that only tells half the story.
The word “burn” here is slightly misleading since not all of the expended energy is turned into heat. Some of it is turned into moving the fan, and by extension, the air around it.

The real question should be: “is the added cooling capacity of the fan enough to offset the increased heat generated by moving it?”. The answer here is probably “yes” since you feel cooler with the fan compared to without. This is mostly due to increased evaporation of sweat with increased air flow.

A more extreme analogy would be cooling systems in a car. The added fans, pumps and electric circuitry actually generate some extra heat, but the increased cooling capacity is more than enough to offset that, leading to a cooler system in total.

You are viewing 1 out of 4 answers, click here to view all answers.