eli5: How do we know that historically accurate things are.. historically accurate?

614 views

Let’s go back to the 1600’s. Stuff happened. How do we know this stuff happened – the way people dressed, ate, acted? Is it a collective of surviving evidence gathered from the time? How do we know that written statements from the time period weren’t bullshit? Do we just agree that we can form a general picture of what happened in the past from the surviving evidence?

(1600s used as an example, this applies to general history. I assume things get more questionable the further you go back)

Thank you for indulging a historically-challenged idiot who’s had a few whiskeys.

In: Other

8 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

You don‘t. There is a „best approximation“ but historically accurate is never 100%, not even close.

Humans are not good historians. We tend to storify history and to interpret intent according to our own mindset.

Example: the outbreak of WW1 is well documented. But even there, historians still have major differences.

You are viewing 1 out of 8 answers, click here to view all answers.