ELI5, what is habeas corpus?

931 views

Layman’s terms. Examples, if you can too, please!

In: Other

10 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Latin for, “produce the body.” Fancypants for, “Why the heck am I here?” It’s an emergency (high priority) procedure in which you ask a judge to get someone in front of the court, along with a government representative. You then ask the government representative, “Why have you arrested / detained this person?” The judge then decides if that person still needs to be detained. Instead of waiting forever to get a court date, HC matters are typically moved to the front of the line.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Other people have done a good job saying what it is, it’s also useful to imagine the opposite. Without habeas corpus, or a similar legal concept in countries with different legal history, the following scenarios may happen.

* The government arrests you and never shows your face again. Maybe you are dead, maybe you are in a work camp, maybe you are in a jail cell. Nobody knows, and nobody has the right to ask.
* Arrest you, give you a day in court, but never accuse you of specific crimes or present evidence. They just say “Nixstar committed crimes against the state, and we think they are guilty” and then throw you in prison.

The above things often happen in dictatorships or corrupted governments, but in a properly functioning government you as the arrested person, your lawyer, or even perhaps a friend or family member can start a process demanding to see you in court. If the judge, police, or other government body can’t or won’t bring you in, then they can be charged with a crime themselves.

Finally, if the government can’t accuse you of a specific crime and show at least SOME evidence for your arrest, then you can demand to be let go. They can still investigate you after letting you go, but they shouldn’t continue to hold you.

Anonymous 0 Comments

‘Habeas corpus’ is the Latin legal maxim that translates to ‘you have the body’ / ‘produce the body’.

The other answers correctly state that it is to affirm that there was good reason for an arrest that was made.

Most countires require that the arrested person be brought before an authority, be it a court or a magistrate or a state attorney, within a certain period of time after arrest, to be charged for what they have been arrested for. It exists for the simple reason of avoiding delaying the judicial process, and more importantly, *ensuring that no innocent man remains in custody for long in case of a wrongful arrest.*

Hence, it is a ***summons with a court order behind it.***

Edit: the summons is made to the custodian of the ‘body’ in question.

Anonymous 0 Comments

I means you need proof that a bad thing was done before you punish the person who did the bad thing.

Anonymous 0 Comments

It means that there is a requirement to produce the accused to a formal court and have the charges presented to them.
It is to ensure that the accused has the opportunity to face their accusers and that this process is transparent.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Basically it is a legal requirement for there to be a legitimate reason for someone to be arrested and detained, the court checks that the reason for detaining the person is legitimate and there wasn’t anything wrong with the arrest.

Anonymous 0 Comments

It literally translates to “may you have the body”. Essentially what it means is that without a body(evidence) there is no proof a crime was committed. What this translates to in modern court is that a person cannot be brought up on trial for a charge without evidence that a crime was committed. In short habeas corpus is the requirement to prove a crime has occured.

Example, you can’t just be charged with speeding because an officer thinks you were speeding, but if they have video or photo evidence of your car speeding then charges could be brought. Still have to prove you were driving though.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Way back, kings could throw people in jail or have their heads cut off for no reason, or on trumped up charges, without a trail, and often without even telling the victim why they were in jail. Magna Carta introduced ‘habeus corpus’ to stop this. It means ‘show the body’, which is meant to mean ‘produce the evidence’. This curtailed the random abuse of power, and began a system where everyone received equal treatment, and had the right to know what the charges against them were, and who their accusers were.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Besides what everyone else has said, in practical terms it also means you get to see a judge, because the judge is who verifies the legitimacy of your arrest.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Nobodies mentioned this either so I’ll chip in an extra tidbit; this actually dates back to the Magna Carta so is legitimately one of the oldest legal concepts still in circulation. Its part of the ‘common law’ so spread to the entire commonwealth/ex-commonwealth very early on in the development of their legal systems. I couldnt speak to the UK or US specifically but its not specifically enshrined in legislation or an act of parliament; its simply one of those legal principles upon which legal thinking is bullt. It does, however carry legal weight when there is an absence of any other specific laws that take precedence.