Player 1 can pick Even or Odd. Player 2 can pick Even or Odd.
The options then are:
1E, 2E – > result is Even
1E, 2O -> Result is Odd
1O, 2E -> Result is Odd
1O, 2O -> Result is Even
Your error is in combining the two options, 1E, 2O and 1O, 2E into one concept of “one picks odd, the other picks even”.
Latest Answers