– Okay, so the solar system is hurtling through space at around 200km/s and by extension so are the planets. I get that we can launch a rocket and land it on another planet, but does this mean that the rocket would also be travelling at approx 200km/s as well?

268 views

And additionally, would it ever be possible to launch something into deep space and get entirely left in the dust by the solar system whizzing by? Completely untethered from its gravity?

In: 9

10 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

In relation to universal space, yes, the rocket would be traveling as fast as the galaxy is moving, as everything in the solar system is already traveling that fast. Think of two pickup trucks driving next to each other, both traveling down a highway at 100 MPH. A guy in the back of Pickup A tosses a basketball to a guy in the back of Pickup B. The guy isn’t throwing the basketball at 100 MPH, but the basketball is still traveling 100 MPH, because the pickup trucks are driving 100 MPH.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Things don’t move unless something makes them move.

But things don’t STOP unless something makes them stop. That’s also true.

Because everything is going 200km/s, and there’s nothing causing it to stop because intergalactic space is almost entirely a vaccuum and there’s nothing out there for it to rub against or impact or push at it, everything will continue going 200km/s until that changes.

The reason we don’t SEEM to be going 200km/s is because everything around us is. If you’re on a passenger train going 50km/hr and you drop your teaspoon, it’s not going 50km/h relative to YOU and in YOUR sight. You just see it drop straight down, bounce, and stop. But it absolutely IS going that speed to someone outside the train that’s watching you go by and looking in your window to see you drop it.

We’re in the galaxy which is our “train” and the rocket is our “teaspoon”. To someone outside the galaxy, it goes by at 200km/s. To everyone inside the galaxy, it’s not. So when it’s on the launch pad or landing site, 200km/s is its speed to galaxy outsiders, but 0 to us. And when it’s in flight it’s going 200km/s to the outsiders, plus or minus a little bit depending on its direction.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Solar system moves across the galaxy with 200km/s means that you have to achieve a higher speed to escape Milky Way, namely about 500km/s. Escape velocity from a solar system can similarly be estimated by velocity of object within the solar system, it’s about 40 km/s. If you manage to achieve 0 velocity relative to Sun, you will collide with it pretty quickly. Similarly if you stop in the reference frame of the Milky Way, you will move to it’s center and collide with something there.

Anonymous 0 Comments

The earth is spinning at around 1000mph, which means that right now, *you* are also moving at 1000mph. But if you’re sitting down, then *compared to the surface of the planet* you’re not moving at all.

So it depends: 200 km/s *compared to what*?

Anonymous 0 Comments

Relative to the centre of the galaxy, yes, but remember that all velocities are defined relative to something else, and that any reference frame is just as good as any other reference frame. So it’s not actually wrong to ignore that 200 km/s and just talk about velocities relative to the planets. That’s all that matters when you’re staying within the Solar system

Anonymous 0 Comments

First of all, you can’t just say “200km/s”. This is because **speed is relative**.

If I say my car is going 80km/h, that means something to you only because we are both on the surface of the earth. The vast majority of the time, we are observing and measuring the speed of things around us relative to the ground. We are so used to having big and seemingly unmoving things around us, that we don’t even think about the fact that we are using them as a reference.

In space, there’s no ground. I know that sounds obvious, but when you think about what speed means when there’s nothing to move relative to, it will be a lot less obvious. Imagine a very lonely planet, that’s the only planet in the whole world. If you looked up at the sky from that planet, even with the best satellites, you would see absolutely nothing. Pitch black all around you. Now: how fast is the planet going?

What does that even mean? You can’t have a speed if you’re the only thing. It has to be you and another thing. Then you can ask “what is my speed relative to that thing?” So before you measure the speed of an object, you have to choose another object as well.

For example, if you tell me the speed of the planets in the solar system is 200km/s, I can whip out my speedometer, point it at the ground, and measure the speed of Earth to be zero (relative to myself, because I’m holding the speedometer). Then I could point to the speedometer and tell you that you’re wrong. But neither of us is wrong, we just chose different reference frames.

The 200km/s number is most likely calculated between the centre of our solar system (which is the sun) and the centre of the milky way galaxy (which happens to be a supermassive black hole called “Sagittarius A*” or Sgr A* for short). The planets also have their own (orbital) speed relative to the sun, so their speed relative to Sgr A* would be different from the sun’s and also periodically changing. Imagine mounting a speedometer to the trunk of a truck, then measuring the speed of cars passing by while doing donuts with the truck. Sometimes the speeds match up and add, sometimes the speeds partially cancel out, sometimes neither.

Now that that’s hopefully clear, we can think about that rocket. Before it launches, its speed is 0 relative to the ground. Relative to the sun, its speed is around 30km/s. Relative to Srg A*, its speed is roughly 200km/s, give or take 30. Relative to someone driving on the highway, its speed is around 100km/h.

You might be tempted to wonder “which of those speeds is the real speed?” but try as hard as you can to really internalise the fact that there is no such thing as a single speed that is the only real one.

You might also notice that I didn’t mention its speed relative to its destination. That’s because with everything like the spin of the Earth around itself and the planets orbiting the sun at different speeds, the speed of the rocket relative to its destination is always changing. Because we don’t want to waste fuel, we usually launch it near the equator and try to time the launch so that the rocket is already heading towards its destination before it launches, basically using all of those spins and orbits as a slingshot. That way, once it climbs out of Earth’s gravity, it doesn’t have to “swim against the current”, so to speak. Of course its destination is not going to stay still while the rocket is on its way, so things are complicated. Not to mention gravity assists and everything else. It’s rocket science after all.

And yes, before during and after the rocket makes its journey from Earth to whatever destination it has (as long as the destination is also orbiting the Sun) its speed relative to Sgr A* stays roughly within that 200km/s range. Yes the rocket speeds up and slows down (acceleration, unlike speed, is not relative) but a kilometre per second is such a crazy large unit of speed that the amound of fuel the rocket has to accelerate is nothing but a rounding error in 200km/s.

And finally for your last question: regardless of the gravity of the solar system, a rocket that launches from the solar system would have around the same 200km/s speed relative to Sgr A*, and it would be orbiting around Sgr A* along with the solar system. The only way to stop doing that is if it was a magical rocket that never ran out of fuel; it could accelerate in the opposite direction until its speed relative to Sgr A* was zero. Then, its speed relative to the solar system would be around 200km/s.

But would that look like being left in the dust by the solar system, or would it look like leaving the solar system in the dust? Is there a difference?

Imagine a helicopter on the ground at the equator. The speed of the ground relative to the centre of Earth is around 460m/s. Before the helicopter takes off, its speed relative to the ground is 0. That means it is also moving at 460m/s relative to the centre of Earth. If the helicopter takes off and just hovers, its speed will be the same from both reference frames. If the helicopter tries to reduce its speed relative to the centre of Earth, it will not look like it’s slowing down. It will not look like the ground is moving away from the helicopter. It will just look like the helicopter is accelerating west.

This is again because we are so used to using the ground as a reference frame. If I crash my car into a wall and tell everyone that the wall was coming towards me really fast, people would laugh at me. “You moved towards the wall, not the other way around!” they would say. But in space, there’s no ground. **There is no difference between the rocket “whizzing by” the solar system and a solar system “whizzing by” the rocket**.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Not “though space”, there is no inherent stationary frame of reference. Solar system is moving around mass center of Milky Way at about 220km/s and yes, so does everything in solar system, everything from rockets to teddy bears included.

If however we don’t care about center of Milky Way and only look at Earth’s orbit around Sun, then that speed is only 30km/s

Speed is always relative to something else. It’s just confusing because in everyday vernacular we are used to assuming that speed is relative to Earth, making us treat speed almost as if it were an absolute quantity, it isn’t.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Speed only has meaning if you’re doing it from a point of reference. We’re all travelling at that 200km/s relative to the center of the galaxy. In our everyday lives we don’t calculate speed from the perspective of the center of the galaxy. Otherwise, you would always be exceeding the speed limit in your car and would probably get jailed for life for driving at 12,000 km/h.

On earth, our point of reference is the biggest thing around. The planet itself. In space that’s no longer the only point of reference to consider. That rocket, from the sun’s frame of reference, is moving at earth’s velocity of roughly 30km/s. It speeds up if it’s going to the outer planets, it’s slowing down if it’s going to the inner planets. Once again, that’s relative to the sun.

As for your second question, shift your frame of reference. The solar system is orbiting the center of the galaxy like earth is orbiting the sun. A spacecraft leaving orbit around the sun would be going into orbit around the galaxy’s center, until you hit escape velocity of the galaxy. Just like how a spacecraft leaving earth’s orbit enters orbit around the sun. Unless you boost its speed to hit the sun’s escape velocity like Voyagers I and II.

Anonymous 0 Comments

When we say that things are moving at a certain speed, we mean to say that they are moving that speed with respect to some point of reference. If you are on an airplane, the plane may be flying 500 mph relative to points on the ground, but when you are in your seat, we say that you’re sitting still because you aren’t moving relative to the plane or your seat.

The solar system is like that plane. For our spacecraft in the solar system, it’s not important how the solar system is moving through space (relative to, say the center of the galaxy). We’re concerned about the movement of things in the solar system so that we can steer the spacecraft to their destination. We are moving completely within the solar system.

This is sort of the starting point for something called “relativity” in physics, and it’s basically simple starts with the idea that the speed of things is measured relative to something else. Relativity get pretty mind-bending after that because how we think of speed changes as things get really fast.

Anonymous 0 Comments

the solar system is travelling at 200km/s RELATIVE to the center of the milky way galaxy. so yes if the rocket is stationary relative to someone in the solar system, then it is also moving 200km/s relative to the center of the galaxy