Why are the conditions for alien life to evolve the same as ours? Why can’t they evolve without water, or extremely far from their sun? Is there a reason for this or is it just because our only example is ourselves?

1.41K viewsBiologyOther

Idk if to put biology or planetary science so ye.

In: Biology

18 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

Think of it like this: space is extremely hostile to biological lifeforms that have DNA:

– cosmic rays that pierce through DNA and cause mutations and decay (necrosis)
– solar radiation that could literally cook any DNA that’s exposed to sufficient quantities, causing cancer and other maladies
– exposure to vacuum prevents any respiratory functions
– nucleonic radiation from, say, a nearby gas giant or super nova, again causing necrosis
– plasma winds from nearby super nova that could strip the atmosphere and the top layer of soil across the entire planet
– extreme cold or heat that prevents any metabolic functions

The list goes on and on. Basically, the only reason we have a biosphere is because the Earth protects us from all those effects:

– our magnetosphere deflects cosmic rays
– our atmosphere diffuses the most harmful blue and UV radiation from our sun
– we have a breathable oxygenated atmosphere, mostly on account of our magnetosphere protecting it from being stripped by the sun
– our magnetosphere also protects us from nucleonic radiation
– there are no nearby super nova
– we are the right distance from the sun to not receive too much radiation, but enough to sustain photosynthesis

There’s a reason why every other planet in our solar system is sterile: they don’t meet any of those criteria. A bit of observation bias due to detection techniques, but nearly all the exoplanets we’ve detected are also likely sterile because either they’re orbiting a red dwarf closer than our moon orbits the Earth, or because they orbit some blue giant that would cook them at any distance.

So what we’re left with is a very narrow range of unlikely conditions:

– a strong magnetosphere
– high water content, but not enough to ensconce every landmass
– high metalicity, rich in things like calcium, phosphorous, and iron
– Goldilocks zone from a stable main sequence star

Find one of those, and you just might find aliens.

You are viewing 1 out of 18 answers, click here to view all answers.