Why aren’t derivatives treated as fractions?

753 views

It’s pretty common to hear that dy/dx isn’t a fraction, but if that’s the case then why do we treat as such in a differential equation or an integral? For example, if dy/dx = f(x), then how can we just write it as dy= f(x)dx as though it’s a fraction?

In: Mathematics

7 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

If you asked a pure mathematician they’d probably tell you never to write:

> dy = f(x) dx

A “dx” thing should never be on its own. You should write:

> ∫ dy = ∫ f(x) dx

The “∫” goes with the “dx”; they are two parts of the same thing. Both “∫[thing] dx” and “d[thing]/dx” are *operators.* They are things we do to functions. They mean “take the function and integrate it with respect to x” and “take the function and differentiate it with respect to x.”

*However*, there are some situations where they do behave similarly enough to fractions that we can kind of treat them like that. If we are careful.

dy/dx can be defined as a limit of a fraction:

> dy/dx = limit as Δx -> 0 of Δy / Δx

where Δy and Δx are separate things. So in the right circumstances, depending on what that limit is doing, you can treat the dy/dx part like a fraction. But you might upset some pure mathematicians.

You are viewing 1 out of 7 answers, click here to view all answers.