Why does common advice stipulate that you must consume pure water for hydration? Won’t things with any amount of water in them hydrate you, proportional to the water content?

350 views

Why does common advice stipulate that you must consume pure water for hydration? Won’t things with any amount of water in them hydrate you, proportional to the water content?

In: 1542

20 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

>ELI5 Why does common advice stipulate that you must consume pure water for hydration? Won’t things with any amount of water in them hydrate you, proportional to the water content?

Not if the body needs to expend more water to separate that water content from the other ingredients. Salt water has approximately the exact same “water content” as fresh water or even distilled water – the differences are rounding errors. Yet it will not hydrate you since your body does not receive those resources in neat separated piles – here’s the H2O, here’s a pile of NaCL – but has to do all the processing itself. And your kidneys can only concentrate salts in your waste to a certain degree, not arbitrarily. So now the body has to *expend* water to dilute the salt water in order to get rid of it.

You are viewing 1 out of 20 answers, click here to view all answers.